Well Prepared Torrent Upload Rewarding
-
i would ask ballard but he doesnt allow his profile being shown which is pointless now because nothing is on there anymore that is personal.
could be a vista glitch. has no trouble making avi or wmv some others, but not mp4, mov, mkv…alas.... -
i would ask ballard but he doesnt allow his profile being shown which is pointless now because nothing is on there anymore that is personal.
could be a vista glitch. has no trouble making avi or wmv some others, but not mp4, mov, mkv…alas....I always use the VLC player. It handles all formats and does great highres screenshots and thumbs…
Maybe not as convenient than a dedicated program but I like the output. -
-
there is no point in having tags if they dont link to all the other torrents that have the same tag. otherwise they're just filler for idiots who cannot figure out from the pics or description what kind of porn it is. and what is the point of adding this sign ~ ?
There is an excellent explanation and description og TAGs (and the importance of ~ char) here:
http://community.gaytor.rent/index.php?topic=13672.0The issue of whether or not tags should be LINKs rather than search parameters is a topic for another, um, topic. (let's not clutter this one up)
-
there is no point in having tags if they dont link to all the other torrents that have the same tag. otherwise they're just filler for idiots who cannot figure out from the pics or description what kind of porn it is. and what is the point of adding this sign ~ ?
There is an excellent explanation and description og TAGs (and the importance of ~ char) here:
http://community.gaytor.rent/index.php?topic=13672.0The issue of whether or not tags should be LINKs rather than search parameters is a topic for another, um, topic. (let's not clutter this one up)
yeah i read it and my opinion is it's filler.
if they were linked it wouldn't be- there would be a use for it.
this is the forum and that's my take on it.
i will still do it to be anal about my posts, but i don't think it helps anyone or that anyone will use them as they stand now…
i also think it is appropriate in this topic because it's one (or two) of the criteria for bonus points for a well-prepared torrent, so clarification and opinions on it seem warranted… -
i have image grabber and mov and mkv are two i recently tried that dont work. any other grabber that will?
These work with Image Grabber II, if you have installed a media splitter and codec to play such files or got Windows 7. I guess you have installed such, if not install Haali Media Splitter to open the .mov, .mp4, .mkv files and ffdshow MPEG-4 (or tryouts SVN built) which adds tons of decoding support.
The trick is that Image Grabber II doesn't know these .mov and .mkv extensions to be AV files (certainly because of it's age and no longer supported), but you can select "show all files" or "." as browsing option bottom right of its window.
-
Congratulations… trial runs well...
There is only one thing.
I don't know if that would be too much work for the moderators but I wonder if it makes sense to award the points immediately at approval time.
This uploader (I assume it's the same in all three cases because the uploads are formatted in a similar way) does very well and gets rewarded for uploads meeting most criteria BUT there seem to be problems with his files!
Of course you guys cannot check the quality of the file at approval but waiting 24 hours before awarding the points gives you the opportunity to see the complaints in the comments section.
I haven't downloaded them myself so I can't tell what's wrong. But there seem to be issues.http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110455
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110496
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110479Fortunately, such not playing issues are quite seldom
Attribution these points takes some extra time, going back 24 hours later to rate will require more work either by reviewing a second time or by keeping well organised the results somewhere aside for 24 hours …
In fact we don't rate the files shared with the torrent, only how it is presented.
-
@Uwe:
i have image grabber and mov and mkv are two i recently tried that dont work. any other grabber that will?
These work with Image Grabber II, if you have installed a media splitter and codec to play such files or got Windows 7. I guess you have installed such, if not install Haali Media Splitter to open the .mov, .mp4, .mkv files and ffdshow MPEG-4 (or tryouts SVN built) which adds tons of decoding support.
The trick is that Image Grabber II doesn't know these .mov and .mkv extensions to be AV files (certainly because of it's age and no longer supported), but you can select "show all files" or "." as browsing option bottom right of its window.
dont understand this. i can play the scenes fine- just when i open the image grabber it errors or doesnt even show the thumbnails in the file for the mp4 or others- (looks empty)
:
and like i said it may be a vista glitch that makes this not work for me like it easily does for others. and it is easy for the files that work. lol
-
I uses Image Grabber II on Windows Vista, not the first version, nor the .net version on which I had trouble to get it work on Vista.
-
A related post to this topic > http://community.gaytor.rent/index.php?topic=15585.msg69812#msg69812
-
and you still didnt give me point for my contact sheets i made which when clicked cover just over the size of the screen and are 300 x 240 and you wonder why i take it personal. did you even click on the contact sheets i made?
[ – ] Contact sheet too small, max. 4 per row if >= 1024 px width, else good
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110556
you also didnt give me a point for my own take which was clearly worded- even more than "- One full sentence of the uploader's own appreciation of the movie"My take on it: The golden blonde dream bottom takes on some of the best cocks in the Falcon canon! Especially good are seeing him take the lesser known, but huge cocks of Damon and Montes.
didnt point me for studio which is worded so many places even like this:
[ – ] Alt. studio/title
Titles: Falcon Anthology Series Vol 22, Best of Derek Cameron, FAS022
Studio : Falcon Anthology Series, Falcon Studios and in the torrent nameand i guess this isnt enough tech info for you to give me a point for this?
Languages: English
Sound: Dolby Digital 2.0 (Primary)
Aspect Ratio: Full-Frame, 1.33
Resolution: 848 x 480
Frame rate: 29f/s
Data Rate: 3220kbps
bitrate: 3284kbps
Digitally mastered
Source: ~web-ripno point for clip identifier which if this doesnt cover it i dont know what would:
Scene Descriptions (*Photos in Scene Order):Scene 1
from "Manhandlers" FVP109
Derek Cameron, Jeff Palmer.
As pool boy Jeff Palmer attends to his duties, he spies Derek Cameron playing with himself poolside. Jeff steps in and gives Derek a thorough workover…leaving the blond spent and soaked.Scene 2
from "The Big Thrill" FVP117
Derek Cameron, Colby Taylor.
Derek Cameron and Colby Taylor find themselves alone. Colby smothers Derek with kisses and slowly they undress each other, sucking, licking, and nibbling on one another. They 69, each one taking the other's cock deep into his throat, contentedly nursing their cocks. Colby runs his fingers over Derek's hole, then stretches it open. He starts to fuck Derek, kissing him intensely on the back of his neck, burying and nuzzling his face against Derek's back. Derek begins to fuck Colby. The sexual energy is non-stop and feverish and the two lovers feed off each other. They bare their cocks and jerk off together, finally shooting thick ropes of cum as they satisfy their lust.Scene 3
from "Fever" FVP119
Derek Cameron, Drew Damon.
Drew Damon and Derek Cameron meet up in the john. Derek drops to his knees and starts sucking Drew's enormous cock. Drew looks down as Derek works and worships his massive tool. Before long Drew's hungry for more...sliding his cock deep into Derek's ass...slamming it in hard and fast and working Derek's load out before delivering his own load of cum.Scene 4
from "Bounce" FVP136
Derek Cameron, Daniel Montes.
Daniel Montes reclines on a couch in briefs. Derek Cameron skillfully works his tongue down over Daniel's muscled chest and onto his huge stiff cock, where he lingers, worshipping it from tip to base. Daniel returns the favor and the men run their hands over each other, their skin tingling in anticipation of the sublime pleasure to come as they work themselves into a frenzy.Scene 5
from "Splash Shots III: To The Hilt" FVP141
Derek Cameron, Roland Dane.
Roland Dane and Derek Cameron lose a frisbee in a neighbor’s pool. As Roland contemplates the floating disk, Derek pushes him into the pool. Determined to teach Derek a lesson, Roland corners him on a picnic table. Derek dutifully devotes some oral service to Roland’s stiff prick. Then Roland returns the favor-sucking Derek and opening his asshole. Roland takes advantage of the open hole, sliding his cock in deep and fucking Derek energetically before the two men surrender to the heat and blow their loads.Scene 6
from "The Dark Side" FVP142
Derek Cameron, Race Jensen.
Daddy Race Jensen fucks his boy Derek Cameron on the kitchen table before feeding Derek just what he needs for breakfast -- a face full of his daddy's cum.Scene 7
from "Deep South - The Big, And The Easy Part 1" FVP144
Chad Hunt, Clay Maverick, Jeremy Jordan, Derek Cameron, Sebastian Cole, Jason Tyler, Adam Wolfe.
Arriving in New Orleans, Josh Weston meets up with old friend Jack Ryan. Josh and Jack cut to the chase and discuss the missing boy. Last time Jack saw him, Jeremy Jordan was being passed around a sex club "like a little doll"...Jeremy serves on one cock after another as a group of hot men have their way with him.Scene 8
from "The Chosen" FVP111
Mike Branson, Jeff Palmer, Michael Lucas, Derek Cameron, Buck Meadows, Travis Wade, Christopher Scott, Paul Morgan, Brian Cruise, and Damon Wolf.
Christopher Scott brings unsuspecting buds Derek Cameron, Paul Morgan and Damon Wolf to the club, where they quickly find themselves the slaves of leather-clad dominators Mike Branson, Jeff Palmer, Travis Wade, Buck Meadows, Brian Cruise and star in the making Michael Lucas. The action is fast and furious, one of the best orgies ever filmed. Cameron bottoms his heart out, while Palmer and Wade help boss the boys around. After a double penetration with Cameron getting fucked by Cruise and Palmer, the men shoot their loads.maybe this site should be called gt.ruwe
-
now this is where you point out i got 18 points when before i would have 0 before your idea.
the whole reason awarding a bonus that i and others brought up was rejected was because it was stated it was too much work for the moderators- now the moderators have made their job even more difficult and involved instead of awarding all uploads a standard bonus and leaving the well prepared torrents to be appreciated by the site members
i am so disappointed in gt.ruwe now.
i was told it wasnt personal when there is no way the points deducted wasnt- particularly when there have been 20 points awarded less comprehensive torrents.
gt.ru couldnt have gone more out of their way to not award points to my torrent if they tried. oh wait, they did try and won.
wonder if this post will now be deleted and when i will be banned from posting in the forum or from the site?
-
We, moderators, can't implement your ideas, even if we wanted to. This is only available to administrators.
Obviously you don't have even the slightest clue of how hard is to maintain such a site working properly, when there are 100k people interacting with it each day, and everybody with his own complaints.
You don't give points to uploaders - no, that's bad, let's complain. You try to give points to uploaders - nope, it's still bad, no objectivity at awarding…
OK xenu, this may be a surprise to you, but you won't find absolute objectivity anywhere. That's life and you have to live with it.
And I'm very sorry you take everything that's going on here so personal.
-
and you still didnt give me point for my contact sheets i made which when clicked cover just over the size of the screen and are 300 x 240 and you wonder why i take it personal. did you even click on the contact sheets i made?
[ – ] Contact sheet too small, max. 4 per row if >= 1024 px width, else good
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110556 ….yes, I clicked on it and even looked to the picture properties. It is 1023 pixel of width, with 5 pictures a row and large black bars between them. So the size of each thumbnail is far below 200 pixel, less than the said 240 pixel in the requirements. You shall have noticed that I earlier said:
@Uwe:…
The first shows there is a glitch in the Picture section, though there are meaningful contact sheets and a few big pictures (most likely from the site), as per the check list, no point is rewarded. I felt it should get a point for "a few good picture". Can someone help to phrase "some good pictures" in something more objective? …No formulation proposal see made by any member yet ….
… My take on it: The golden blonde dream bottom takes on some of the best cocks in the Falcon canon! Especially good are seeing him take the lesser known, but huge cocks of Damon and Montes. ...
Sorry didn't see that. Point added.
… didnt point me for studio which is worded so many places even like this:
[ – ] Alt. studio/title
Titles: Falcon Anthology Series Vol 22, Best of Derek Cameron, FAS022
Studio : Falcon Anthology Series, Falcon Studios and in the torrent name …That is not an alternative Studio or Distributor, nor another title. Just completing the title … This point is dedicated to the mention of the same movie distributed in other parts of the world with different branding and / or titles, e.g. early Cazzo by All Worlds Video > Cazzo - Pralle Lederhosen = All Worlds Video - Bulging Bavarians
… and i guess this isnt enough tech info for you to give me a point for this?
Languages: English
Sound: Dolby Digital 2.0 (Primary)
Aspect Ratio: Full-Frame, 1.33
Resolution: 848 x 480
Frame rate: 29f/s
Data Rate: 3220kbps
bitrate: 3284kbps
Digitally mastered
Source: ~web-rip ...Not enough, the video codec isn't mentioned, bit rates are not given split between audio and video. Else it is good.
… no point for clip identifier which if this doesnt cover it i dont know what would:
Scene Descriptions (*Photos in Scene Order):Scene 1
from "Manhandlers" FVP109
Derek Cameron, Jeff Palmer.
As pool boy Jeff Palmer attends to his duties, he spies Derek Cameron playing with himself poolside. Jeff steps in and gives Derek a thorough workover...leaving the blond spent and soaked.Scene 2
from "The Big Thrill" FVP117
Derek Cameron, Colby Taylor.
Derek Cameron and Colby Taylor find themselves alone. Colby smothers Derek with kisses and slowly they undress each other, sucking, licking, and nibbling on one another. They 69, each one taking the other's cock deep into his throat, contentedly nursing their cocks. Colby runs his fingers over Derek's hole, then stretches it open. He starts to fuck Derek, kissing him intensely on the back of his neck, burying and nuzzling his face against Derek's back. Derek begins to fuck Colby. The sexual energy is non-stop and feverish and the two lovers feed off each other. They bare their cocks and jerk off together, finally shooting thick ropes of cum as they satisfy their lust.Scene 3
from "Fever" FVP119
Derek Cameron, Drew Damon.
Drew Damon and Derek Cameron meet up in the john. Derek drops to his knees and starts sucking Drew's enormous cock. Drew looks down as Derek works and worships his massive tool. Before long Drew's hungry for more...sliding his cock deep into Derek's ass...slamming it in hard and fast and working Derek's load out before delivering his own load of cum.Scene 4
from "Bounce" FVP136
Derek Cameron, Daniel Montes.
Daniel Montes reclines on a couch in briefs. Derek Cameron skillfully works his tongue down over Daniel's muscled chest and onto his huge stiff cock, where he lingers, worshipping it from tip to base. Daniel returns the favor and the men run their hands over each other, their skin tingling in anticipation of the sublime pleasure to come as they work themselves into a frenzy.Scene 5
from "Splash Shots III: To The Hilt" FVP141
Derek Cameron, Roland Dane.
Roland Dane and Derek Cameron lose a frisbee in a neighbor’s pool. As Roland contemplates the floating disk, Derek pushes him into the pool. Determined to teach Derek a lesson, Roland corners him on a picnic table. Derek dutifully devotes some oral service to Roland’s stiff prick. Then Roland returns the favor-sucking Derek and opening his asshole. Roland takes advantage of the open hole, sliding his cock in deep and fucking Derek energetically before the two men surrender to the heat and blow their loads.Scene 6
from "The Dark Side" FVP142
Derek Cameron, Race Jensen.
Daddy Race Jensen fucks his boy Derek Cameron on the kitchen table before feeding Derek just what he needs for breakfast -- a face full of his daddy's cum.Scene 7
from "Deep South - The Big, And The Easy Part 1" FVP144
Chad Hunt, Clay Maverick, Jeremy Jordan, Derek Cameron, Sebastian Cole, Jason Tyler, Adam Wolfe.
Arriving in New Orleans, Josh Weston meets up with old friend Jack Ryan. Josh and Jack cut to the chase and discuss the missing boy. Last time Jack saw him, Jeremy Jordan was being passed around a sex club "like a little doll"...Jeremy serves on one cock after another as a group of hot men have their way with him.Scene 8
from "The Chosen" FVP111
Mike Branson, Jeff Palmer, Michael Lucas, Derek Cameron, Buck Meadows, Travis Wade, Christopher Scott, Paul Morgan, Brian Cruise, and Damon Wolf.
Christopher Scott brings unsuspecting buds Derek Cameron, Paul Morgan and Damon Wolf to the club, where they quickly find themselves the slaves of leather-clad dominators Mike Branson, Jeff Palmer, Travis Wade, Buck Meadows, Brian Cruise and star in the making Michael Lucas. The action is fast and furious, one of the best orgies ever filmed. Cameron bottoms his heart out, while Palmer and Wade help boss the boys around. After a double penetration with Cameron getting fucked by Cruise and Palmer, the men shoot their loads. ...That is an item in the list for which I wanted to give examples anyway. It is in the Pictures section, not description, and meant to "replace" the DVD or cassette cover item for clips from web-sites : a picture from the site with the title of the clip. An example will make it clear.
-
The initial post has been edited by adding in 2 new points and modifying one:
-
an item for numbering of movies, clips or TV series provided
-
an item for 3 SD pictures from the upload
-
10 pictures have no special requirement (but must be related to the upload according to the site rules)
Next step is to apply these changes for a few days.
Then follows the trial to publish the check list differently (most likely in the member's trial section)
Finally, I have decided to limit this trial to 2 weeks, because of the findings so far:
- much work
- no feedback at all from uploaders having got points except 1 (not being happy)
- general feedback allowed already to fine-tune the scheme
- my summer holidays :cheers:
-
-
@Uwe:
and you still didnt give me point for my contact sheets i made which when clicked cover just over the size of the screen and are 300 x 240 and you wonder why i take it personal. did you even click on the contact sheets i made?
[ – ] Contact sheet too small, max. 4 per row if >= 1024 px width, else good
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110556 ….yes, I clicked on it and even looked to the picture properties. It is 1023 pixel of width, with 5 pictures a row and large black bars between them. So the size of each thumbnail is far below 200 pixel, less than the said 240 pixel in the requirements. You shall have noticed that I earlier said:
@Uwe:the black bars between them is because it is a full frame movie (1:33) and the screen is 16x9 to keep the proper aspect ratio. i was going by what YOU asked for in your very rigid criteria of what is "good". also it does not say it HAS to be or MUST BE 4 rows only. so this is a prime example of you LOOKING for things wrong, not checking a list. and you wonder why it's personal. no one else would have not given a point for this except you, Uwe.
…
The first shows there is a glitch in the Picture section, though there are meaningful contact sheets and a few big pictures (most likely from the site), as per the check list, no point is rewarded. I felt it should get a point for "a few good picture". Can someone help to phrase "some good pictures" in something more objective? …No formulation proposal see made by any member yet ….
… My take on it: The golden blonde dream bottom takes on some of the best cocks in the Falcon canon! Especially good are seeing him take the lesser known, but huge cocks of Damon and Montes. ...
Sorry didn't see that. Point added.
surprised you admit you made a mistake.
… didnt point me for studio which is worded so many places even like this:
[ – ] Alt. studio/title
Titles: Falcon Anthology Series Vol 22, Best of Derek Cameron, FAS022
Studio : Falcon Anthology Series, Falcon Studios and in the torrent name …That is not an alternative Studio or Distributor, nor another title. Just completing the title … This point is dedicated to the mention of the same movie distributed in other parts of the world with different branding and / or titles, e.g. early Cazzo by All Worlds Video > Cazzo - Pralle Lederhosen = All Worlds Video - Bulging Bavarians
**and one would know this, how? guessing. why is this even a criteria?
so even though the film has alternative titles that i included- it is known as The Best of Derek Cameron, it is known as FAS022, and it is known as Falcon Anthology Series Volume 22- these are not alternative titles to you? hence no objectivity, one was supposed to read your mind, what you "meant" not what you wrote…**
… and i guess this isnt enough tech info for you to give me a point for this?
Languages: English
Sound: Dolby Digital 2.0 (Primary)
Aspect Ratio: Full-Frame, 1.33
Resolution: 848 x 480
Frame rate: 29f/s
Data Rate: 3220kbps
bitrate: 3284kbps
Digitally mastered
Source: ~web-rip ...Not enough, the video codec isn't mentioned, bit rates are not given split between audio and video. Else it is good.
… no point for clip identifier which if this doesnt cover it i dont know what would:
Scene Descriptions (*Photos in Scene Order):Scene 1
from "Manhandlers" FVP109
Derek Cameron, Jeff Palmer.
As pool boy Jeff Palmer attends to his duties, he spies Derek Cameron playing with himself poolside. Jeff steps in and gives Derek a thorough workover...leaving the blond spent and soaked.Scene 2
from "The Big Thrill" FVP117
Derek Cameron, Colby Taylor.
Derek Cameron and Colby Taylor find themselves alone. Colby smothers Derek with kisses and slowly they undress each other, sucking, licking, and nibbling on one another. They 69, each one taking the other's cock deep into his throat, contentedly nursing their cocks. Colby runs his fingers over Derek's hole, then stretches it open. He starts to fuck Derek, kissing him intensely on the back of his neck, burying and nuzzling his face against Derek's back. Derek begins to fuck Colby. The sexual energy is non-stop and feverish and the two lovers feed off each other. They bare their cocks and jerk off together, finally shooting thick ropes of cum as they satisfy their lust.Scene 3
from "Fever" FVP119
Derek Cameron, Drew Damon.
Drew Damon and Derek Cameron meet up in the john. Derek drops to his knees and starts sucking Drew's enormous cock. Drew looks down as Derek works and worships his massive tool. Before long Drew's hungry for more...sliding his cock deep into Derek's ass...slamming it in hard and fast and working Derek's load out before delivering his own load of cum.Scene 4
from "Bounce" FVP136
Derek Cameron, Daniel Montes.
Daniel Montes reclines on a couch in briefs. Derek Cameron skillfully works his tongue down over Daniel's muscled chest and onto his huge stiff cock, where he lingers, worshipping it from tip to base. Daniel returns the favor and the men run their hands over each other, their skin tingling in anticipation of the sublime pleasure to come as they work themselves into a frenzy.Scene 5
from "Splash Shots III: To The Hilt" FVP141
Derek Cameron, Roland Dane.
Roland Dane and Derek Cameron lose a frisbee in a neighbor’s pool. As Roland contemplates the floating disk, Derek pushes him into the pool. Determined to teach Derek a lesson, Roland corners him on a picnic table. Derek dutifully devotes some oral service to Roland’s stiff prick. Then Roland returns the favor-sucking Derek and opening his asshole. Roland takes advantage of the open hole, sliding his cock in deep and fucking Derek energetically before the two men surrender to the heat and blow their loads.Scene 6
from "The Dark Side" FVP142
Derek Cameron, Race Jensen.
Daddy Race Jensen fucks his boy Derek Cameron on the kitchen table before feeding Derek just what he needs for breakfast -- a face full of his daddy's cum.Scene 7
from "Deep South - The Big, And The Easy Part 1" FVP144
Chad Hunt, Clay Maverick, Jeremy Jordan, Derek Cameron, Sebastian Cole, Jason Tyler, Adam Wolfe.
Arriving in New Orleans, Josh Weston meets up with old friend Jack Ryan. Josh and Jack cut to the chase and discuss the missing boy. Last time Jack saw him, Jeremy Jordan was being passed around a sex club "like a little doll"...Jeremy serves on one cock after another as a group of hot men have their way with him.Scene 8
from "The Chosen" FVP111
Mike Branson, Jeff Palmer, Michael Lucas, Derek Cameron, Buck Meadows, Travis Wade, Christopher Scott, Paul Morgan, Brian Cruise, and Damon Wolf.
Christopher Scott brings unsuspecting buds Derek Cameron, Paul Morgan and Damon Wolf to the club, where they quickly find themselves the slaves of leather-clad dominators Mike Branson, Jeff Palmer, Travis Wade, Buck Meadows, Brian Cruise and star in the making Michael Lucas. The action is fast and furious, one of the best orgies ever filmed. Cameron bottoms his heart out, while Palmer and Wade help boss the boys around. After a double penetration with Cameron getting fucked by Cruise and Palmer, the men shoot their loads. ...That is an item in the list for which I wanted to give examples anyway. It is in the Pictures section, not description, and meant to "replace" the DVD or cassette cover item for clips from web-sites : a picture from the site with the title of the clip. An example will make it clear.
all this info was NOT on any one page or site. i looked up each movie by title after figuring it out by who the scene partner was (also researched not on the site) and found all 8 and then gave the breakdown for each movie and compiled them. gave the title and item number for each film the clip was taken from. doesnt matter. Uwe doesnt think this extra work means anything and unworthy of a point. looks for something else to deduct instead….
-
the whole point is i went out of my way to meet all your criteria and gave probably the most thorough description i have ever seen on this site, just to show you would still not rate it well, because you are not objective and you proved it.
hahahaha
-
Like I stated in an earlier post, I think what started out as a good intention has become an overly thought and bloated and instead of leading to rewarding, it's leading some to feel like they're being punished for what they feel is hard work, but "not hard enough" according to others.
Do some people care about the codec? I'm sure some do. I don't. I'm not sure a lot of people do.
Care about alt-title? Maybe some do. Not sure may, though.
How about:
Is the title correct? Yay. Is it in all upper and lower case letters, capitalized correctly? I don't care.
Is the box cover included? Yay. Additional pictures? Yay. If not, I'm not gonna lose sleep.
Is there a url included for further info? Yay! If not, that's why I always have a tlavideo and aebn.net window open. I'm capable of searching for myself.
Are there a few tags included? Yay! If not, again, tlavideo and aebn.net.
For me, that's all I need to make a decision of whether or not I want to download.
The size of the pictures? Not a problem.
Bit rate? Huh?
At the risk of sounding snarky, at this point, I'm thankful for being my auto-approval status. No expectations…no disappointment.
-
I've well recognized that a lot of efforts were done with that description and just showed that despite of it, the objectively verifiable criteria which were layout weren't full meat.
Of course the criteria listed are chosen with a personal target of what makes a good description, and the one here discussed is a good IMHO (and got 19 points !), but still each point is objectively verifiable.
Please all notice this has been from the beginning a trial and to put emphasis on it, the word trail is no put in bold size 4 letters in the opening post. It was always there. It is not meant to be definitive or ultimate. It is subject to changes during the trial.
This trial in live permits to test and fine-tune that list and the details of the criteria, as well as their formulations.
I regret that when asking for help to formulate an objectively verifiable criteria for what a few good pictures mean, no proposal was made. Instead at the next occasion there is complaint that no points were given for (such) pictures …
Until someone gets up with a better definition it is :
"- 3 pictures from the movie, clip or picture collection, size at least SD size (576 pixel width, height at least 40% of width) or the resolution of the movie"To note that with the latest adaptation of the criteria this morning, the before discussed torrent upload would have meat 21 points and gotten therefore the 20 max.
-
I'm not sure to whom your post was directed, Uwe, since you didn't quote any post. My point isn't to argue with you. In fact, I do applaud your efforts to respond to the point that people feel an uploader should be rewarded for efforts in addition to what they end up seeding to leeches. My main point is, "what do members really consider to be important factors in deciding to download a torrent?"
Maybe my tastes are simple. As I stated in the post above, all I really care about are an accurate title, a few pictures to tell me if the guys/scenes are hot enough, and some tags for whichever kinks appeal to me.
Anyway, like I said, I do applaud your efforts to respond to members' wanting rewards for their efforts.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login