What torrent client should I use?
-
@Aestet OK. Is this also a cost issue, or is it just there's a multiple users in the household all using the same VPN? If so, do they have their own computer each, or is it a shared computer too?
-
Cost. I have my own computer. I would rather spend my money on other things instead of a seperate vpn and antivirus when I have one available like this
-
@Aestet OK. Well, you have two options then:
Do your torrenting not hidden behind a VPN. This has big risks in that you could be identified as doing so, and face civil and criminal penalties if caught.
Manually connect to every McAfee server to test if that one allows P2P. And, according to what my AI has just told me, not only do they not publish a list but the ones that do allow it may be subject to change. Don't know how often this might happen, but it's another factor to consider. You may find one that works then find in a few weeks or months that it no longer does, and have to go through the process all over again.
-
Dang it
-
@Aestet Yeah. McAfee don't seem to be the best for this. Much closer to the bottom of the list!
-
Hmm. One thought. You could ask here. Start a new thread: "Anyone know which McAfee VPN servers support P2P?"
-
alright I'll do that!
-
@Aestet Good luck with it. Don't think I can help anymore where we're at. Happy to try though, if you get new info, or once you decide how you're going to proceed and have questions like "Why did the torrent I uploaded not work?"
-
Cost. I have my own computer. I would rather spend my money on other things instead of a seperate vpn and antivirus when I have one available like this
The problem you're not considering is this: the VPN is not only for your privacy/safety in this particular case. When you're connected to the IP that was assigned to you by your internet provider, chances are that your computer will not be reachable from other computers on the internet. This means that you'll be able to download stuff just fine, but your ability to upload will be significantly restricted.
Over time the result is obvious, your ratio will plummet and your download rights will be suspended.
That's why it's important that you have a VPN that supports port-forwarding. That is, it must not only "work" with P2P but also provide you with the option to get your own open port number.
Many VPNs, specially free ones, have some servers that will allow P2p traffic, so you can actually use them in your client, but they don't offer port-forwarding. The result is that you're on the exact same situation as you'd be using your regular IP: you're not reachable from the internet, no one will be able to connect to your client.
Hopefully this makes sense but if you have any questions feel free to ask.
-
have some servers that will allow P2p traffic, so you can actually use them in your client, but they don't offer port-forwarding. The result is that you're on the exact same situation as you'd be using your regular IP: you're not reachable from the internet, no one will be able to connect to your client.
Hopefully this makes sense but if you have any questions feel free to
Uh- So should I get a seperate vpn? If it's cheap, I could do it, any recommendation that will have p2p and port-forwarding?
-
@Aestet I use Proton. Someone else I was chatting to a short while ago uses Torguard. There are a few around, so the best thing to do is investigate a little to find the best deal for you. The important things are that they support P2P and offer port forwarding. This sometimes depends on what package you sign up for, or is offered at an additional cost, so work out what the bottom line is before signing up.
You should have no problems running whichever one you opt for while other in your household stay on McAfee. Just don't try to run both on the same computer at the same time. Things can get very complicated and confused that way!
-
Just checked this from the server side. The tracker itself is up and healthy, and your client's announces are actually reaching it right now without any problem. Your own upload registered fine too and is currently seeding with a healthy swarm. So nothing is broken on the site or your account.
The 'Not working' tracker status you saw is almost always the VPN in the middle. Antivirus bundle VPNs like McAfee's are not made for torrenting: no port forwarding, and P2P traffic is often blocked or throttled. Kevin's advice is spot on. Test for a few minutes without the VPN, and if it works then, the VPN is the culprit. If you want to keep using a VPN for torrents, pick one that supports port forwarding and bind qBittorrent to it.
One more thing: older torrents with only a few seeders can sit at 0 peers or 'stalled' for quite a while even when everything is configured right, so give those some time.
Quick self test: if https://tracker.gaytor.rent/stmdd loads in your browser, your connection can reach the tracker fine.
-
Proton
From protonvpn.com or proton.me??
-
on other thread someone said privatevpn is good and seems like its cheaper than protonvpn. but proton is european
-
@Aestet They're basically just two routes to the same thing. I opted for Proton because I got a really good deal for twelve months on a package that gives me VPN, email, a password manager, and cloud storage. My primary goal in changing VPNs was to get port forwarding, but I also have a goal of breaking as many links with US tech - such as Micros**t and Google - as possible.
-
This link takes you to a "Compare plans and prices" page. As I say, I opted for the Unlimited so I got everything. The free offering doesn't support P2P or port forwarding.
-
Proton works and is safe, right? I'm willing to go for their VPN plus
-
@Aestet It's certainly working for me. Port forwarding was far easier to set up than I thought it would be too. Safe? Well, the police haven't knocked on my door yet, so I guess so. Though I have only been using it a couple of weeks, tbh.
-
@Kevin4fm You've been very helpful to me, I'll just try it, ig?
Nothing ventured, nothing gained ig?
-
@Aestet Absolutely. It costs a few pounds / euros / dollars, but it's only money. Seems like you have no choice anyway, as McAfee doesn't support you, but I gave up on ExpressVPN with about 18-20 months left on a 24m contract, mainly for the port forwarding.
You won't experience this, but I've been torrenting for ages without it, and having to really work on keeping my ratio up, and issues connecting to torrents with only one or two seeders. With port forwarding, I'm constantly seeding 15-20 torrents at my highest upload speed most of the time!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login