Well Prepared Torrent Upload Rewarding

Popper

it is probably better anyway to give an example of a movie torrent formatted the way you see it as thorough
and also a clip torrent done "perfectly"
at least as far as text- the photo requirements have been over explained

You will see as comment to each (by me) reviewed and rewarded torrent the Well Prepared Torrent Upload Reward Check List. This makes transparent for what a point has been given and for what not.

The criteria may be adjusted as per the different contributions made here. The initial post will be revised accordingly. Remember, this is qualified a trial.

No one is taken anything, every one has the possibility to get extra points. If some torrents can't reach the maximum 20 points because of their type, possible.

Popper

@xenu:

… most all of this seems standard for a good torrent ...

:true: So it should be easy to get a lot of extra points rewarded

@xenu:

… what does 3 tags, then 5 tags mean? do you mean 8? ...

1 point if in total 3 tags are made, 2 points if in total 5 tags are made.

@xenu:

… to me a tag is like "falcon, redhead, fucking, sucking, rimming, brent, brent_corrigan, daddy" so i don't know why you have 2 separate criteria... ....

This refers to http://community.gaytor.rent/index.php?topic=13672.0 (needs to be added to the initial post) and excludes tags from the Table Q Quality and Origin tags (for codec and resolution information is given another point)

@xenu:

… if no "director" is given in clips (i.e. Sean Cody has no "director", neither do the "next door" clips) or in the movie (vintage maybe or compilation) does that mean no 20 points possible ? ...

Yes, the standard isn't met fully.

@xenu:

… "Source"? would an example of this be "dvd" or downloaded off web or what? "avi" or "wmv" it is unclear to me ...

This is to indicate from what type of support the file was created. DVD, website download, analogue video tape, analogue or digital TV recording etc… This can be done by words or by the tags of the Table Q Quality and Origin (move the mouse on the tags to see more information in that table). Together with information of the resolution, codec and bit rates, it gives some indicator to the picture quality which can be expected.

@xenu:

… "Archived pics"? whether we had them or found them on here? where we saved them from? it is unclear to me
it may be better to give an example of these items …

The idea behind is that if in the torrent's files (the files share by the help of the torrent) are more than 10 pictures, these are provided in as an archive file (ZIP, RAR, …) in order not to clutter the file list and make identifying the movie or clips difficult. I think as well to add or combine a point for having provided the description pictures within the torrent's files (therefore without "gaytor.rent" imposed) at least for the full DVD cover if DVD format video.

@xenu:

… what of banned studio images? no 20 points possible? ...

Could be included in the torrent's files, however as they are banned here, I don't like to give points specifically for such images.

@xenu:

… also- some formats don't work for making contact sheets- at least the two i use don't do ALL of them. ...

Except DVD Video, I have no issue to create a contact sheet with Image Grabber II from any format. Which doesn't work for you? For DVD Video, VLC or MPC should allow to make contact sheets

raphjd

I'm not too worried about who the director is.

Also, every part of the torrent should be in mixed capitalization (big and small letters) used properly, not just the title.

Popper

@raphjd:

… Also, every part of the torrent should be in mixed capitalization (big and small letters) used properly, not just the title.

Fully right, there was just a bad example this morning. I'll need to see how this can be built-in, without exceeding 20 points. I can't effort more, they will melt like ice cream in the sun.

BTW Xenu is right, the count to 20 got some bugs depending if porn, collection or themed movie.

UPDATE: With the latest revised list, between 23 and 17 items can be meat:

Porn DVD 23
Porn Movie 22
Porn Clip 20 - 21
Porn Collection 20 - 21
Themed DVD 22
Themed Movie 21
Themed Shorts collection 20 - 21
Music track collection / album 17 - 18

There will be a cap at 20 points, means it is easier to get them or close to it.

Popper

Please vote if you see the result check boxes of the check list well aligned.

geographer

@Uwe:

… they will melt like ice cream in the sun.

Knowing the current situation, I'm not so sure about that

Popper

Yep, even with such low standard no upload reviewed yet got close to 20 …

ballard1

Uwe, I am pretty sure not many guys are aware of the trial ratings system because not too many people bother to check out the forum.
Since it's only a trial and not all moderators are participating it probably doesn't make too much sense to announce it on the browse page.
But at least one guy was really happy about it: http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110401
:cheesy2:

Good work!
And yes: the Admin should reimburse you for the points you are handing out. After all they can "print" as many as they like…

leatherbear

I will gladly contribute my points for Uwe's new "Well Prepared Torrent Program" :cheers:

Popper

I prefer to proudly earn my Seed Bonus points my self and show that good ratio and gifting SBP is not incompatible >:D

geographer

@leatherbear:

I will gladly contribute my points for Uwe's new "Well Prepared Torrent Program" :cheers:

Count me in too.

I'm just not sure how, and where, are we supposed to mark the reason of the gifted SBP.

leatherbear

With Brandon I just pick an upload and gift that upload.Usually 400 points or so at a time. I then leave a comment explaining the extra seed bonus points that have been gifted.

I prefer to proudly earn my Seed Bonus points my self and show that good ratio and gifting SBP is not incompatible

Does this mean you do not want the extra SBP's?

ballard1

@Uwe:

I prefer to proudly earn my Seed Bonus points my self and show that good ratio and gifting SBP is not incompatible >:D

Well, just in case you run low I will gladly donate points to you :hug:

junior

Sounds and looks good, I was just randomly giving points but this has sustance…. now I just hope we don't have any whiners about why so and so got points and they didn't....

Popper

[b]Well Prepared Torrent Upload Reward Check List[/b]
[font]
[b]TITLE[/b]
 [  ] Content        
 [  ] Numbering     
 [  ] No periods          
 [  ] Not all caps        

[b]PICTURES[/b]
 [  ] Cover               
 [  ] Clip identifier     
 [  ] Contact sheet       
 [  ] 3 pictures SD
 [  ] 10 pictures         

[b]DESCRIPTION[/b]
 [  ] Not all caps        
 [  ] Alt. studio/title   
 [  ] Comprehensive       
 [  ] No"�"               
 [  ] Clips/tracks List   
 [  ] Own appreciation    
 [  ] Director            
 [  ] Actor(s)            
 [  ] 3 tags              
 [  ] 5 tags              
 [  ] Coding info         
 [  ] Source format       
 [  ] No mention SBP      

[b]FILES[/b]
 [  ] File names          
 [  ] Pics incl./archived
 [  ] DVD large full cover

[b]APPROVAL[/b]
 [  ] No message sent     

[b]   X [/b]/ 20 MAX. [b]POINTS GIVEN [/b]           
[/font](for details see http://community.gaytor.rent/index.php?topic=15622 )

Well Prepared Torrent Upload Reward Check List

TITLE
[ ] Content
[ ] Numbering
[ ] No periods
[ ] Not all caps

PICTURES
[ ] Cover
[ ] Clip identifier
[ ] Contact sheet
[ ] 3 pictures SD
[ ] 10 pictures

DESCRIPTION
[ ] Not all caps
[ ] Alt. studio/title
[ ] Comprehensive
[ ] No"�"
[ ] Clips/tracks List
[ ] Own appreciation
[ ] Director
[ ] Actor(s)
[ ] 3 tags
[ ] 5 tags
[ ] Coding info
[ ] Source format
[ ] No mention SBP

FILES
[ ] File names
[ ] Pics incl./archived
[ ] DVD large full cover

APPROVAL
[ ] No message sent

X / 20 MAX. POINTS GIVEN
(for details see http://community.gaytor.rent/index.php?topic=15622 )

Popper

@junior:

… now I just hope we don't have any whiners about why so and so got points and they didn't....

There will be always such type of members. The answer to them is simple: These are our Seed Bonus Points we give at our discretion. It is not a right of them, which can be claimed.

Popper

The first two days of trial show that it is important to practice it, to get a feeling how the set-up works.

A few well rewarded torrent uploads:
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110479
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110483

The first shows there is a glitch in the Picture section, though there are meaningful contact sheets and a few big pictures (most likely from the site), as per the check list, no point is rewarded. I felt it should get a point for "a few good picture". Can someone help to phrase "some good pictures" in something more objective?

I feel as well, that for some items, points should not be given, but rather deducted from the elsewise given points:

for having the title and/or description in ALL CAPITALS
for having the "�" sign in the title or description
for asking for Seed Bonus Points

That would give the room for more 3 more "Picture" items

Comments?

geographer

Maybe we could make a general entry, something like using a decent char set in title and description, that will include the useless caps and unreadable symbols.

As for the SBP begging: I still think this should be taken into account separately.

And I have a question: what do we do if the description is entirely not in English? It would be hard to analyze its content.

geographer

For a live example of everything that's been said here: http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110496

Note the checklist in the comment.

ballard1

Congratulations… trial runs well...
There is only one thing.
I don't know if that would be too much work for the moderators but I wonder if it makes sense to award the points immediately at approval time.
This uploader (I assume it's the same in all three cases because the uploads are formatted in a similar way) does very well and gets rewarded for uploads meeting most criteria BUT there seem to be problems with his files!
Of course you guys cannot check the quality of the file at approval but waiting 24 hours before awarding the points gives you the opportunity to see the complaints in the comments section.
I haven't downloaded them myself so I can't tell what's wrong. But there seem to be issues.

http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110455
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110496
http://tracker.gaytor.rent/details.php?id=110479