Is this a duplicate file?

[lovebearlove]

let s say…post A (which is a file pack) was posted earlier

is post B(a single file which has the same format，size，duration time and content with a single file from post A ) a duplication of post A？

what do u think？

[cannonmc]

Well I would say it is a duplicate but whether it would come under the heading of a different posting format because it was a single file I don't know.

Perhaps you could report it and see what happens

[spam17]

Well in that case it isn't a duplication..

It is a repeatition-highlight of a specific file!

;D

[cannonmc]

Fortunately I don't have to make the decision

[Priest]

From my understanding you are asking if and we will assume just for this purpose that if the files names are the same the format and file size are the same i.e. A=A, B=B, C=C same format and size +/- 10%

Torrent X
Contains files: A,B,C,D,E,F.

Torrent Y
Contains file C

From my understand as long as A,B,C,D,E,F are all video files then torrent Y is not a duplicate. Duplicates may be accepted when part of a themed collection.

Now if A,B,D,E,F are image files it would probably fall under the +/- 10% rule.

[lovebearlove]

@Priest:

From my understanding you are asking if and we will assume just for this purpose that if the files names are the same the format and file size are the same i.e. A=A, B=B, C=C same format and size +/- 10%

Torrent X
Contains files: A,B,C,D,E,F.

Torrent Y
Contains file C

From my understand as long as A,B,C,D,E,F are all video files then torrent Y is not a duplicate. Duplicates may be accepted when part of a themed collection.

Now if A,B,D,E,F are image files it would probably fall under the +/- 10% rule.

that s very helpful.. :laugh:..is that saying….if someone uploaded a torrent Y (a,b ,c d, e......all videos)..... i can upload a solo file which is contained in Y already?

[Popper]

Yes, unless there is already a torrent Z for that solo file