New Icons

[longaius]

And if colored tiles were used it would look like this

[SuitAndTieX]

@longaius:

Ok
Here are the text only icons with an underline of color as would look on smartphones.

I would say the underline of colour needs to be fatter to be able to be seen. Especially on phones.

It looks as if one could use smaller hieght tiles but the square tile is better to touck on on phones.

NOTE
The off center of the list is how it is displaying at present.
I would say centering them would look better.

Also note:
Category icon tile size in this category list appears at 60 x 60 pixels

I particularly liked their result with the transparent background and I agree when you say that underlining needs to be fatter. I think that if you make the underline a little fatter and without any color degradation effect, it should be much better.

As for the colors, I found the colors very vivid, very prominent, looking at them on a website where the background is predominantly dark, it doesn't look very nice.

[bearbearbear]

Some comments from the peanut gallery:

They are looking great and seeing them all together confirms that not using illustrations is the right direction, especially on a phone-sized screen.

The font should be the same size for all of the icons.  Otherwise, unintended emphasis is given to the icons with the larger font and it's more difficult to scan or browse the entire list because the brain has to adjust and readjust over and over again.

I agree that centered would look better and might be easier to read.

The icons with the same grey background and the colored underlines look best and are much easier to browse compared to the ones with the colored backgrounds.

I don't think the colors are actually helpful in navigating and finding a category.  That goes for both sets, grey with colored underlines and colored backgrounds.  The color is decorative and a bit of distraction, especially with colored backgrounds, not so much with the colored underlines.

Since there are so many categories, alphabetical order makes sense and is helpful even for long-time users.  Currently, I search for themed films more than anything else, and having the icons in browse mode and the list in search mode placed in alphabetical order is very helpful when I go to check that box or select that icon.

[longaius]

Existing Icons

Comared with possible new icons

[bearbearbear]

@longaius:

Existing Icons

Comared with possible new icons

The new ones that are easiest to read and quickly understand the meaning of are the ones without the pictograms, on the third row from the bottom.

[longaius]

@bearbearbear:

@longaius:

Existing Icons

Comared with possible new icons

The new ones that are easiest to read and quickly understand the meaning of are the ones without the pictograms, on the third row from the bottom.

Made a mistake in using a bigger font on those in third row from the bottom so they are easier  to read than the others.
Font size needs to be smaller to accomdate longest category title.

[bearbearbear]

@longaius:

Made a mistake in using a bigger font on those in third row from the bottom so they are easier  to read than the others.
Font size needs to be smaller to accomdate longest category title.

That may be part of it but primarily they are easier to read because they have no pictogram, just text.

[ben351500]

I agree with Bearbearbear. The text-only version is the easiest to read, particularly at a glance. The icons created are a lot of fun, but still… As I have said before:

Less is more

[bearbearbear]

@ben351500:

I agree with Bearbearbear. The text-only version is the easiest to read, particularly at a glance. The icons created are a lot of fun, but still… As I have said before:

Less is more

Yeah, I don't want to come across as if I don't appreciate the creativity and work that went into them because I do.

[thangcuoi]

I vote for the text over pictogram.

The white text on dark background version has the most clean professional look.

The version with the colour background needs to be several shades more subdued, and it does not needs the colour underline.