American Idol , The Voice or X factor?
-
Which one of these three shows is better
-
Which one of these three shows is better
I don't watch either, but if I was to pick it would be The Voice…maybe X factor. They really need to find another 'voice' like Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood.
-
Which one of these three shows is better
I used to watch all 3 of them, but they have become more about popularity as opposed to actual singing talent. American Idol has really gone down the tubes, thats probably why this next 2016 season will be its farewell swan song. It's time for it to go though, I think its run its course. Over the past few years it has become more about who can scream the loudest, and so many good ones are passed over and sent home. Xfactor is no longer in the USA. The Voice is pretty good, they have some decent singers, but they are all prescreened so much, you can tell its all set up. It is entertaining though and the singing is good. American Idol I'll watch since its the last year and its goodbye. If it wasnt the last year for it, I wouldnt be watching.
Like the previous poster said, we need another Carrie or Kelly, and until that is found, its mostly going to be pretty boring. No one has ever even come close to either one of them career wise. Adam Lambert I think is very talented, but hes kind of doing his own weird thing, which works well for him.
-
The Voice just won Emmy Awards and for me that's an obvious direction this past years.
Like the previous said, we definitely need more like Kelly and Carrie in these kind of competition.
-
Don't like this kind of shows, but The X Factor gave us the amazing Matt Cardle, so I'd go with that
-
Which one of these three shows is better
I used to watch all 3 of them, but they have become more about popularity as opposed to actual singing talent. American Idol has really gone down the tubes, thats probably why this next 2016 season will be its farewell swan song. It's time for it to go though, I think its run its course. Over the past few years it has become more about who can scream the loudest, and so many good ones are passed over and sent home. Xfactor is no longer in the USA. The Voice is pretty good, they have some decent singers, but they are all prescreened so much, you can tell its all set up. It is entertaining though and the singing is good. American Idol I'll watch since its the last year and its goodbye. If it wasnt the last year for it, I wouldnt be watching.
Like the previous poster said, we need another Carrie or Kelly, and until that is found, its mostly going to be pretty boring. No one has ever even come close to either one of them career wise. Adam Lambert I think is very talented, but hes kind of doing his own weird thing, which works well for him.
Yeah I agree it's not about talent anymore
-
The voice
-
i quite like the voice actually
-
The voice
-
I liked AMERICAN IDOL THE BEST!! however the show got stale and their attempt to bring in viewers by creating juding controversy and the same song and dance year after year just grew stale and unfortunately the voice overtook it and became a ratins giant with different aspects.
you gotta continue to evolve instead of being the same thing each year but I will stick with AI even though it was not good the last few years
-
X Factor all the way….it gave us Fifth Harmony. Plus, I like the setup of the show better....even though they all run along the same lines
-
:hug2:
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login