Lord of the rings vs Hobbit vs Game of thrones?

[forgetjack]

YAY Lord of the Rings still

[Jason23]

Lord of the Rings. 

[forgetjack]

Still no one can beat LoTR

[oliblo]

GoT though both Lotr & Hobbit are good

[duyduk]

I haven't seen Hobbit nor GOT and I didn't like LOTR

[AlexGardino]

It's Game of Thrones for me, but LOTR is not that bad. I just love how GoT focused more on the characters and philosophies of men, and how realistic its fantasy seems to be.

[gaypraha2]

I guess the question is about the adaptation for the tv and for the silver screen..
I guess in that case it's gonna be very hard for Game of Throne to beat the marvelous , incredible shots from New Zeland you have in LOTR captured on Red cams. I mean the views are so ecstatic.
Game of throne is not bad but it's mostly CG for large shots. Besides it's difficult to compare a movie to a tv show. That's not the same kind of production at all..(time , money..)
Now about the storytelling, GOT is not bad but it's not as innovative as LOTR.. GOT is largely inspired from the Druon books " les rois maudits" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Accursed_Kings ) with fantasy elements. LOTR marks a revolution in literature. I mean Martin might be good but he's no Tolkien..

[eastonkellan]

LOTR trilogy especially their extended versions 

[jdo143]

@eastonkellan:

LOTR trilogy especially their extended versions 

Agreed.  The Hobbit was a bit of a disappointment, in particular the The Battle of the Five Armies.  Shame! 

[eastonkellan]

@jdo143:

@eastonkellan:

LOTR trilogy especially their extended versions 

Agreed.  The Hobbit was a bit of a disappointment, in particular the The Battle of the Five Armies.  Shame! 

Maybe because LOTR is a trilogy books which was adapted into trilogy film while Hobbit is a single book that was thinly spread out to a trilogy film