My straight marine special friend I perv on on Skype finally took the plunge in September and this was his first butt toy purchase, the blue one, the smallest size. Since then, he promptly bought a medium sized pink plastic one with a clear jewel in October. He does use both, but he definitely favors the first one. It seems easier to wear out, fit in his mouth, fuck himself with in lieu of a proper dildo. I know he can fill himself up quite a bit with other objects, but he seems to take the pink very seriously. Not as much room to move it around.

I just double checked with him and he got medium metal and blue and large pink and clear, my mistake. Ain't nobody got time for small buttplugs. So good news: the large is large, and the medium is a good time.