But the pumping muscle versioning affair is getting to far. There are four or five sets of collections and four or five versions of the same video.

My suggestion to avoid this and refrain this collection and versioning is a modification in the rule that says that active torrents with the same content already in the tracker must be in the first line of the description.
I.e. people has to look if another "pumpingmuscle" "jacob 1" is already present and if there is cite it the description.

as:
ALTERNATIVE VERSIONS
P ump ing  Mus cle  Jac ob  1  2015 4GB file version:
http:/nameoftheurlofthebiggerorsmalleractivetorrent.
etc..

If not used the duplicate button should be used to alert the original publisher to add that info or the torrent will be deleted.