Johnny Bravo (can't be beat as far as cocky BIG  bodybuilder bullies go)

Diesel (guy had an over the top aggressiveness that I found insanely hot combined with his deep voice and those awesome pair of bowling ball biceps)

Vinny (Was an absolute adonis and perfect heel, though he was much hotter in attitude and body during his first stunt than his current one. Thunder's wrestler I would most like to see do nude matches since he's clearly hung like a horse, check out his huge dick outline in his match against Mogly)

Kratos (damned if this guy isn't one of the sexiest men on the planet with that brick hard furry bod, sexy voice, big bulge, and he-man attitude. An amazing dominator, needs to come back)

Marco (one of the most erotic wrestler's they've ever had and now that he's recently packed on the muscle he looks like an absolute adonis)

Coupe (jacked like no one's business and a perfect muscle jobber)

Ace Hanson (Loved his mat wrestling and when he sported the furry muscles)

Impact (just a flat out sexy wrestler)

Uno (same as Impact, just oozing with sexiness in his matches)

Troy Stevens/Xframe/Boxxy (grouped together since all only did one or two matches, but they were on Bravo's level of hot and huge bodybuilder dominators. Xframe's match against Cameron Matthews is an all time favorite)

Some of my other favs would be:
Titan
Sampson
Big Sexy
Eric Fury
Bam Bam
Dominic
Xavier
Iceman
Devin
Dozer
Conan
Brian Cage
Bolt
Talon

cmon now everyone knows big sexy is the hottest.  has he ever been naked in a vid?

Not yet

And I like the new guys:
Anarchy
Jersey
Talon